Papa with Carlie, Makena, and Trey Carlie wanted her picture alone with him I look like I really cooked a big meal or something! The kids gave him a card and present As soon as I found out that Papa's 84th birthday was on a Wednesday, I started making plans to have a dinner and cake and ice cream for him. Grammy was working, Carl was working, and my parents were out of town, so I planned to have it at our house with me and the kids (nobody should be alone on their birthday!). I'm sure it wasn't as big of a deal to him as me, but when you turn 84 it IS a big deal! I think he enjoyed the meal and especially time with the kids. He has 10 great grand kids, but my three live closest and are very close to him. Happy Birthday, Papa!! We love you and hope you have many more :) Beth